The Person Who Says Yes Is Not Always the Person Who Can Spend
Let me tell you about a deal that looked perfect right up until it wasn't.
The account executive had been working a large operations software opportunity for four months. The VP of Operations loved the solution. She sat through every demo, brought her directors to the workshops, and told the account executive more than once, "This is exactly what we need." When it came time to choose, she said the words every seller wants to hear: "We are going with you."
The account executive asked the question he was trained to ask. "Are you the decision maker?" She said yes, and she meant it. It was her team, her budget line, and her project.
The deal went to Commit at $180,000.
Two weeks later, the VP called back. The CFO had reviewed the purchase and frozen it. The company policy required CFO approval for any new software commitment over $100,000, and the CFO had just been asked by the board to cut operating expenses by 8 percent. The first thing on the chopping block was a brand-new $180,000 annual commitment.
The VP had not lied. She was the decision maker. She was just not the Economic Buyer. And nobody had ever met the person who was.
What Is the Economic Buyer?
The Economic Buyer is the person who can say yes when everyone else says no, and who can say no when everyone else says yes.
That is the simplest definition I know. The Economic Buyer has discretionary authority over the money. They don't need anyone's permission to spend it, and they can find money outside the budget if the business case is strong enough. Just as important, they can stop a purchase that everyone below them has already approved.
Notice what that definition does not say. It doesn't say the person who likes your product most. It does not say the person who runs the evaluation. It does not say the person whose team will use the software. It also doesn't say whose name goes on the contract.
Those can all be different people. Sometimes they are the same person. The mistake is assuming they are the same person without proving it.
Three Roles Sellers Confuse All the Time
After hundreds of deal reviews, I see the same three roles get blended together again and again. Here is how I separate them:
Role | What they actually do | Example |
Decision Maker | Chooses the vendor. Owns the evaluation and the recommendation. | The VP of Operations who picks your solution |
Economic Buyer | Controls the money. Can approve, reprioritize, or stop the spend. | The CFO who must approve anything over $100,000 |
Contract Signer | Puts a signature on the paper once everything is approved. | A controller or the general counsel with signing authority |
The Decision Maker answers, "Which vendor?" The Economic Buyer answers, "Should we spend this money at all, and should we spend it now?" The signer simply executes what has already been decided.
That last row trips up many sellers. The person who signs the contract is not automatically the Economic Buyer. In many companies, a controller, a procurement director, or legal counsel has signing authority, but they have no say in whether the money gets spent. They sign what the Economic Buyer has already approved. If you find out who signs and stop there, you may still have never met the person who can kill your deal.
What Selling to the Wrong Yes Actually Costs
Let's go back to our account executive and look at what happened next.
The VP of Operations went back to the CFO and fought for the project. The CFO did not say no forever. He said, "Not this year, and not at that price." After another six weeks of back-and-forth, the deal closed at $120,000 instead of $180,000, with a smaller rollout and a promise to revisit the rest next year.
Here is the math:
$60,000 a year in lost contract value. A 33 percent reduction, on a deal the customer had already chosen.
Two quarters of delay. The deal slipped out of the quarter it was forecast in, then out of the next.
A weaker champion. The VP had to go back to her team and explain why the project they had been promised was being cut in half.
Now here is the part that should bother every sales leader. The CFO didn't oppose the solution. When the account executive finally got 20 minutes with him, the CFO said the operational savings were real. His problem was that nobody had ever shown him how this purchase helped him hit the 8 percent cost reduction the board had asked for.
The business case existed. It was just presented to the wrong person. The VP cared about her team's productivity. The CFO cared about operating expenses. Same solution, completely different reason to buy.
Stop Asking "Are You the Decision Maker?"
That question almost always gets a yes. People like to think of themselves as the decision maker, and in their world, they usually are. The question is not wrong. It is just incomplete.
Instead, ask questions that reveal how money actually moves in the company:
"The last time your team made a purchase of this size, who had to approve it before it could move forward?"
"Is there a dollar threshold where a purchase needs approval above your level? Where does this one fall?"
"Is this project already in this year's budget, or does the money need to come from somewhere else?"
"If this project competed with another priority for the same money, who would decide which one gets funded?"
"Who owns this budget, and what are they being measured on this year?"
"Has anything changed recently? New leadership, a cost-cutting initiative, a spending freeze?"
Question five is my favorite. Once you know what the Economic Buyer is measured on, you know how to frame the business case. In our story, the answer would have been, "The CFO has to cut operating expenses by 8 percent." That single answer would have changed the entire deal.
And notice that none of these questions require you to go around your champion. You are not asking to skip anyone. You are asking your champion to help you understand how their company makes spending decisions, which is something a real champion will want you to know.
Test Yourself: Do You Really Know Your Economic Buyer?
Pick your biggest open opportunity and answer these five questions honestly. Give yourself one point for every question you can answer with a specific name, number, or fact.
Can you name the one person who could stop this deal even if everyone else approved it?
Do you know the dollar threshold that requires their approval?
Do you know what that person is measured on this year, in their own words?
Have you, or your champion, connected your Metric to that measurement?
Has anyone on your team actually spoken with them?
5 points: You have identified the Economic Buyer. Keep testing it as the deal moves.
3 to 4 points: You know who it is, but you are relying on your champion to carry a message you have never tested. Ask your champion to help you get in front of them.
0 to 2 points: You probably have a Decision Maker, not an Economic Buyer. That deal is at risk, no matter how much the team loves your solution.
If you are honest, most deals in most pipelines land in the middle. That is not a failure. It is a to-do list.
🎬 Take Action
List your top five opportunities.
For each one, write down three names: the Decision Maker, the Economic Buyer, and the Contract Signer. If the same name appears in all three boxes, prove it before you believe it.
Run the five-question self-test on each deal and write down the score.
For any deal scoring 0 to 2, ask your champion this week: "The last time your team made a purchase this size, who had to approve it?"
For every Economic Buyer you can name, write one sentence connecting your Metric to what they are measured on.
Move any deal without a confirmed Economic Buyer out of Commit until you have one.
Remember, the person who says yes is not always the person who can spend. Find the one who can say no, and make sure they have a reason to say yes.
Comments